High Set vs Low Set Engagement Rings: Which One Fits Your Finger Shape Better?
When you are choosing an engagement ring, the cut of diamonds and size may be the determining issue, but the style of setting plays a role. It doesn’t make a difference whether you choose an oval, pear, round, emerald or different shape; the manner in which the diamond is seated in the setting might drastically change the appearance of the diamond, as well as its wearability.
Before you decide between the low-set ring and high-set ring, it is important to take into consideration how each setting will affect your finger’s shape and your everyday life. Our engagement ring settings come in a range of profiles, with something to suit every style and lifestyle. Profile refers to the general height and overall ease of wear of the ring. Different profiles will suit different needs, and is based entirely on your personal preference.
Read our comprehensive ring profile guide here.
What Is a Ring Setting?
A ring’s setting is where the diamond’s centre stone is set on the band. Setting may also be used to describe the design (halo solitaire, bezel, halo and so on). When it comes to this topic, it’s all about the setting height– how high or low your diamond rests on your finger.
The setting height is the most important element of the ring’s design and feel. It also influences how the diamond reacts to light, the way it is paired with wedding rings, and how it complements your hand.
At Nature Sparkle, we’ve conveniently categorized all of our ring settings into one of three categories to help you find the fit that is right for you:
- Comfort Fit: A low profile that sits closer to the finger.
- Lustre Fit: Medium profile, and has a balance of aesthetics and wearability.
- Astra Fit: A showstopper that features an elevated, sophisticated design that places the centre stone in the spotlight.
How Can You Tell the Difference Between High and Low Settings?
There’s no exact measure to determine if a setting is low or high; however, the distinction is typically obvious to the naked eye. At Nature Sparkle, we note on each ring’s product page whether the profile is Comfort, Lustre, or Astra.
- Astra: In high settings, the diamond is set in a High setting, the diamond is prominently above the band. It is often seen as if it “hovers” over your finger and allows more light to pass through the diamond from all angles.
- Lustre: A medium profile setting has an even balance of aesthetics and wearability. The stone isn’t set exceptionally high and still allows for comfortable, everyday wear.
- Comfort: In the case of a lower setting, the diamond sits closer to the fingers and is often more incorporated within the band. It could appear slightly receding or encased within the ring.
The distinction between a high-setting diamond and a low-setting diamond could be subtle or dramatic; however, each one has its own aesthetic and functional characteristics.
Characteristics of High Settings
A high setting puts the centre stone farther away from the hand, creating a distinct space between the top of the diamond as well as the upper part of the band. We’ve named high-profile fits Astra Fit. This design can be said to:
- Make sure you emphasize the brilliance and size of the diamond.
- Allow light to penetrate from a variety of directions to increase sparkle
- You can easily pair it with the majority of wedding bands to make a perfect fit
High settings are great for centre diamonds that you would like to show off and designs that have intricate prongs and ornate settings.
A high setting may not be the best choice for certain diamond shapes or styles of life. For instance, long-cut diamonds like emerald and marquise in high settings are vulnerable to being caught in. If you are a frequent user of the hands or use gloves for protection, then a less pronounced cut may make you feel more relaxed.
Characteristics of Low Settings
In a ring with a low set, the diamond is placed closer to the hand, sometimes dropping into the band to create a slim and compact look. We’ve coined low-profile settings as Comfort Fit. This type of setting can be described as:
- Provide a more minimalist and modern design
- Give extra protection to the diamond
- Reduce the chance of catching on surfaces or clothing.
Low-heeled shoes work best with natural or delicate styles and are ideal for people who have active lifestyles.
Although low settings provide excellent longevity, they could pose issues in stacking rings. Since the diamond is situated near the fingers, the ring might not be able to match flush with traditional wedding rings.
How to Choose the Right Setting for Your Finger Shape
The decision between a low-set ring or a high-set ring isn’t only about fashion; it is also based on how you proportion your fingers and hand.
- Fingers with short lengths: Benefit from setting them to low that visually elongates the fingers and ensures an even appearance.
- Long fingers: Frequently accompany high settings. They give depth and shine to the diamond.
- Wider fingers: Might appear more proportionate in an upper setting that emphasises the vertical height.
- Petite hands: Usually work better with lower settings since they appear less gaudy as well as less heavy.
If you’re still not sure you’re not sure, try both the low and high settings in person to see what feels most comfortable and flattering.
Consider Your Lifestyle
Beyond your finger’s shape and choice, consider your day-to-day routines. “Think about your lifestyle and the way you want to wear your jewelry,” says one of our design experts on Nature Sparkle.
If you have to work using your hands, look after your children, or are involved in an active lifestyle. The advantages of a low-setting engagement ring are not difficult to overlook. Lower settings offer greater security as well as less snagging and better quality of life.
However, when you are at your desk or prefer a more elevated appearance, the high setting will be very effective and allow the diamond in your jewelry to sparkle with no obstruction.
Is There a Middle Ground Between High and Low?
The technical term for rings is as low or high set, however, certain designs can create the illusion of a balanced shape. We’ve coined these medium-profile settings Lustre Fit. The cathedral or basket setting, for instance, raises the diamond slightly, but still keeps the ring near the hand. These types of settings provide visual height, without the risk of snagging or discomfort.
Can You Pair a Wedding Band With Any Setting?
But if you would like your wedding ring to fit flush against the engagement ring, then the setting height is important.
- The highest settings: Generally permit wedding bands to be tucked carefully under the centrepiece stone.
- The low settings: Might require an angled or a contoured wedding band in order to eliminate gaps.
If stacking is a priority for you, we recommend putting your wedding ring and engagement band together. You can also consult with experts to make sure you get the right match.
Final Thoughts
The decision to choose between the choice of a high setting and a lower setting diamond is more than aesthetics. Consider your finger’s shape and the routine of your day preference for stacking, as well as your comfort. There are both strong and practical considerations for both sides. But ultimately, your ring should reflect your personality.
You may be drawn by the dramatic look of a solitaire set in a high-setting or the elegant and subtle advantages of a lower-setting diamond engagement band.
Still unsure? Check out our selection of rings or connect directly with our experts in the field to help you find the best setting for your lifetime wedding ring.